Pre-tax vs. Publish-tax Deductions – What is the Distinction?


In case you present advantages to workers, you most likely surprise easy methods to withhold wages for the advantages correctly. Do you withhold the premiums and contributions earlier than or after taxes? Are you able to select to withhold nevertheless you need? Nicely, it will depend on the profit. So, you need to perceive the distinction between pre-tax vs. post-tax deductions.

Pre-tax vs. post-tax deductions

You’ll withhold pre-tax deductions from worker wages earlier than you withhold taxes. Pre-tax deductions scale back the quantity of earnings that the worker has to pay taxes on.

You’ll withhold post-tax deductions from worker wages after you withhold taxes. Publish-tax deductions haven’t any impact on an worker’s taxable earnings.

Some advantages might be both pre-tax or post-tax, resembling a pre-tax vs. post-tax 401(okay) sorts. Usually, the kind of deduction it’s essential to make is predefined within the coverage for the profit. Generally, you or the worker might need the choice to decide on whether or not or not a profit has pre-tax vs. post-tax deductions.

Under is a breakdown of every sort of deduction.

pre-tax vs. post-tax chart

Pre-tax deductions

Take away pre-tax profit deductions from worker pay earlier than you deduct payroll taxes.

Pre-tax deductions supply the advantage of decrease tax liabilities for each you and the worker. Nevertheless, the worker may owe taxes sooner or later after they use the advantages. For instance, an worker who retires will owe taxes after they withdraw cash from a pre-tax 401(okay) plan.

Additionally, not all pre-tax advantages are exempt from all federal tax withholdings. For instance, adoption help is exempt from federal earnings tax withholding. However, adoption help just isn’t exempt from Social Safety and Medicare taxes, or FUTA tax.

Use Publication 15 and Publication 15-B to search out out which pre-tax advantages are exempt from every federal employment tax.

Some pre-tax advantages could or is probably not exempt from state and native taxes. Examine your state and native legal guidelines to search out out what profit deductions are exempt from taxes.

Widespread pre-tax deductions

Widespread pre-tax deductions embody:

  • Some retirement plans (resembling a 401(okay) plan)
  • Medical health insurance
  • HSAs and FSAs
  • Life insurance coverage
  • Transportation applications

You may have to withhold a few of these deductions after taxes primarily based on the insurance policies what you are promoting has arrange.

Pre-tax instance

Let’s say your worker, Peter, earns $500 per week. Peter contributes 5% (0.05) per pay interval to a pre-tax 401(okay) plan.

Whenever you start payroll withholdings, you’ll first withhold the 401(okay) contribution as a result of it’s pre-tax.

$500 X 0.05 = $25

You’ll withhold $25 from Peter’s wages and deposit the quantity to his 401(okay) account.

Now it’s essential to calculate how a lot of every tax to withhold. The 401(okay) contributions are exempt from federal earnings tax withholding, so you’ll not embody the contribution when calculating earnings tax.

$500 – $25 = $475 (whole wages taxable by federal earnings tax)

Based mostly on IRS Publication 15-T, a single one who earns $475 and is paid weekly owes $19 in federal earnings tax (utilizing the usual withholding quantity).

The 401(okay) contribution is taxable for Social Safety and Medicare taxes.

$500 (whole wages taxable by Social Safety and Medicare taxes) X 0.062 (worker Social Safety tax price) = $31

Withhold $31 from Peter’s wages for the worker portion of the Social Safety tax. You additionally have to pay the matching employer portion.

$500 X 0.0145 (worker Medicare tax price) = $14.50

Withhold $14.50 from Peter’s wages for the worker portion of the Medicare tax. You additionally have to contribute the matching employer portion.

In the long run, Peter’s take house pay is $410.50 ($500 – $25 – $19 – $31 – $14.50).

A deferral to a 401(okay) account is taxable for federal unemployment tax (FUTA tax). This implies the entire $500 is topic to FUTA tax. Solely employers pay FUTA tax.

Publish-tax deductions

You’ll subtract post-tax deductions from worker pay after you deduct payroll taxes.

You and your worker owe extra payroll taxes with post-tax deductions. Nevertheless, the worker received’t owe taxes on the advantages when utilizing the advantages sooner or later. For instance, an worker who retires is not going to owe further taxes after they withdraw cash from a post-tax retirement plan.

Since you withhold taxes earlier than you withhold profit contributions, all federal, state, and native taxes are already paid on the contributions.

Widespread post-tax deductions

Widespread post-tax deductions embody:

  • Some retirement plans (resembling a Roth 401(okay) plan)
  • Incapacity insurance coverage
  • Life insurance coverage
  • Garnishments

You may have to withhold a few of these deductions earlier than taxes primarily based on the insurance policies what you are promoting has arrange.

Publish-tax instance

Let’s say your worker, Carole, earns $500 per week. Carole contributes 5% (0.05) per pay interval to a post-tax retirement plan.

You’ll first withhold any payroll taxes. The entire paycheck is topic to federal earnings tax withholding.

Based mostly on Publication 15-T, a single one who earns $500 and is paid weekly owes $21 in federal earnings tax (utilizing the usual withholding quantity).

The entire paycheck can be topic to Social Safety and Medicare taxes.

$500 (whole wages taxable by Social Safety and Medicare taxes) X 0.062 (worker Social Safety tax price) = $31

Withhold $31 from Carole’s wages for the worker portion of the Social Safety tax. You additionally have to pay the matching employer portion.

$500 X 0.0145 (worker Medicare tax price) = $14.50

Withhold $14.50 from Carole’s wages for the worker portion of the Medicare tax. You additionally have to contribute the matching employer portion.

After taxes, Carole’s wages quantity to $433.50 ($500 – $21 – $31 – $14.50).

Now that you simply’ve withheld taxes, you’ll be able to withhold the post-tax deduction for Carole’s retirement plan. Carole’s gross wages are topic to her contribution of 5%.

$500 X 0.05 = $25

You’ll withhold $25 from Carole’s wages for her retirement account.

In the long run, Carole will take house $408.50 ($500 – $21 – $31 – $14.50 – $25).

A comparability

As you’ll be able to see, Carole can pay extra in taxes than Peter.

On this case, Peter has a larger internet pay than Carole. An worker’s internet pay will rely upon their tax bracket and their whole deductions.

Peter will owe taxes sooner or later on the cash he makes use of from his retirement account. Carole is not going to owe taxes on her retirement account withdrawals sooner or later.

Make pre-tax and post-tax deductions simple by utilizing Patriot Software program’s on-line payroll software program. We’ll precisely do the calculations for you, so that you don’t have to fret about errors. Begin your free trial at present!

This text has been up to date from its unique publication date of March 15, 2017.

This isn’t meant as authorized recommendation; for extra info, please click on right here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *